Product Promotion Network


Are new wireless speakers from John Lewis and Argos any good?

After releasing a number of speaker-like radios, John Lewis has now released a dedicated speaker. And Argos has gone one step further by getting in on the smart-speaker trend with its own-brand cylindrical speaker with Amazon’s Alexa voice control built in, at a much lower price than most comparable rivals. But are either of them a Best Buy or Don’t Buy?

At only GBP40, the John Lewis Polka is for those looking for an entry-level speaker with stereo sound and contemporary looks. Its small size means you’ll easily find space for it and it has a useful handle for carrying it around the house. It’s portable, too, so you can take it out into the garden or for a trip to the park.

Meanwhile, Argos’s own-brand Acoustic Solutions Wireless Speaker with Alexa (AS1) is exactly what it says. Following the cylindrical design common to the new wave of smart speakers, such as the Apple HomePod[1], Amazon Echo (2nd Gen)[2] and Sonos One[3], at only GBP100, the AS1 dramatically undercuts both the Sonos One and Apple HomePod and serves as a similarly priced alternative to the Amazon Echo (2nd Gen). The included Alexa voice assistant allows you to control your music hands-free from across the room and also allows you to ask your speaker questions, such as what the weather will be like today or for news and traffic updates.

See what we thought of these new retailer wireless speakers by clicking on the links to our full reviews below. Best Buy wireless and Bluetooth speakers[4] – skip straight to our list of recommendations.

John Lewis Polka, GBP40

John Lewis claims this modern-styled portable Bluetooth wireless stereo speaker will add ‘zest and dynamism’ to your music collection. It allows you to play your music collection wirelessly from your smartphone or other Bluetooth device, and also has an aux-in port, so you can plug in your music via a wired connection as well.

Simply power it on and it will search for devices to connect with. Tap on the Polka in the Bluetooth menu on your device and you’re ready to go – and you only have to do this once. From then on, just press the Bluetooth button to connect automatically when in range.

It has a built-in rechargeable battery that John Lewis claims will last for a full eight hours – our tests reveal whether the battery really lasts this long or even exceeds it. Could this be the ideal purse-saving wireless speaker for your home? Find out in our John Lewis Polka review[5].

Acoustic Solutions Wireless Speaker with Alexa (AS1), GBP100

Smart speakers are occupying an increasingly big space on the wireless speaker scene, with seemingly every wireless speaker brand looking set to add voice assistants to their speakers, so you can control them hands-free with just your voice.

However, they can be very expensive, with music-focussed smart speakers, such as the Sony LF-S50G[6] and the B&O Beoplay M3[7], costing upwards of GBP150 if you’re lucky, and often far more. Argos’ Acoustic Solutions brand aims to solve this, giving retail customers who are interested in seeing what a smart speaker has to offer a cheaper entry-level alternative. You can find out more about these devices and what they can do in our guide to how to buy the best smart speaker[8].

The Argos model gives you the same deep access to Alexa – through ‘skills’ (like apps on your smartphone) you can use your smart speaker for a whole variety of things, from simply playing and pausing music, and asking for a song to be played, to setting kitchen timers and asking it to remind you to do things at a later date. You can even order things from Amazon directly through the speaker without having to get out your PC or smartphone. The AS1’s cylindrical design helps to distribute sound evenly throughout the room and, unlike the Amazon Echo (2nd Gen),[9] it also allows you to connect your music collection to it via a wired connection – useful if your laptop doesn’t support Bluetooth or you have a flakey Bluetooth connection.

Has Argos brought a worthy reasonably priced smart speaker to the high street?

We give our verdict in our Acoustic Solutions AS1 review[10].


  1. ^ Apple HomePod (
  2. ^ Amazon Echo (2nd Gen) (
  3. ^ Sonos One (
  4. ^ Best Buy wireless and Bluetooth speakers (
  5. ^ John Lewis Polka review (
  6. ^ Sony LF-S50G (
  7. ^ B&O Beoplay M3 (
  8. ^ how to buy the best smart speaker (
  9. ^ Amazon Echo (2nd Gen), (
  10. ^ Acoustic Solutions AS1 review (

Smart speakers to look out for in 2018

The tail end of 2017 saw a whole suite of smart speaker launches, including the Sonos One, Ultimate Ears Megablast, Amazon Echo Show and more, with Sony and JBL also getting in on the action. In 2018 we expect smart speakers to continue to launch thick and fast from even more manufacturers. Here are details of the smart speakers to expect this year.

Market analyst Canalys expects the global smart speaker market to double year on year to more than 50 million speaker sales in 2018, and it’s no longer just Amazon’s Echo and the Google Home dominating. Electronics heavyweights Samsung and LG are entering the market this year with the launch their first smart speakers. Apple has just launched its HomePod and Google will rival this with the launch of the audio-focussed Google Home Max.

So big is the potential of the new smart speaker market that new players are getting in on the action as well. Facebook is set to enter the hardware scene with large-screen speakers to rival the Amazon Echo Show, bringing its social media platform to the speaker space, and even music streaming giant Spotify could be coming into the picture. Best Buy wireless speakers[1] – see whether any of the smart speakers we’ve tested made the cut.

LG’s ThinQ smart speaker

LG’s ThinQ smart speaker is due to launch this April.

It’s powered by Google Assistant for voice commands, which will allow you to play music by requesting an artist or song with your voice, change the volume or even ask Google questions on topics such as the weather, news or traffic. The ThinQ will also act as a smart hub for other LG products around your home, such as for turning on its LG purifier, and LG has teamed up with British high-fidelity audio specialists Meridian Audio to work on the sound – like Amazon did with Dolby for the Echo Show[2]. The speaker will support lossless High Resolution Audio, a defining feature that could make the speaker popular with audiophiles.

No pricing has yet been revealed, but LG is aiming at the premium end of the market where rivals such as the Sonos One[3] and Sony LF-S50G[4] launched around the GBP200 mark. Similar to these rivals, the ThinQ’s design is a tall cylindrical shape, which helps dissipate the sound, and it has touch controls on the top. Could the LG ThinQ be the standout Google Assistant speaker?

See how previous LG wireless speakers have fared in our LG speaker reviews[5].

Google Home Max

The heat has been on for Google since Amazon updated its Amazon Echo speaker range at the tail end of last year, with a particular emphasis on improving its speakers’ sound. While the Google Home 2 seems distant, the Google Home Max aims to provide a more audio-focussed companion to the Google Home.[6] Both are controllable with your voice with Google Assistant. Uniquely, the Google Home Max is one of the first smart speakers with stereo sound.

It also has more powerful speakers than the Google Home, with a new rectangular design more akin to traditional speakers and curved edges. It can be positioned either horizontally or vertically to fit your room space. It’s due to launch in the UK in early 2018, having already launched in the US.

In the US it costs £399 and comes with a 12-month free subscription to YouTube Music for music streaming. The Google Home Max is positioned as a rival to the music-focussed Apple HomePod[7], but appears to be targeting an audience more similar to those who buy the popular Beats headphones, with a strong bass compared to the more balanced sound production on the HomePod. Powered by dual 4.5-inch high-excursion woofers, Google says the Google Home Max is as much as 20 times as powerful as the original Google Home, and it is also considerably larger.

It will be available in white or black-grey and, similar to the Sonos One and Google Home, it includes room-optimisation technology. It will automatically adjust its sound output, adjusting the volume depending on where it is in your house, and will also tune itself, aiming to produce the best possible even distribution of sound throughout the room regardless of its shape. Google says it can do this within seconds.

The Google Home Max supports multi-room so you can link several of the speakers together for sound throughout your home, as well as Chromecast support so you can link to other Chromecast-enabled speakers. Unlike the HomePod[8], it also supports Bluetooth and aux-in, which allows you to use your Google Home Max as your dedicated speaker for other devices such as your computer or record player. Similarly, in contrast to the restrictive Apple HomePod, the Google Home Max has support for a wide variety of music services built in, including YouTube, Spotify (notably both free and paid subscriptions), Google Play Music, Deezer and others.

Samsung’s Bixby-powered smart speakers

Samsung is now due to enter the smart speaker market a little later than expected, in the second half of 2018. Its first smart speaker will be powered by its own Bixby voice assistant.

The tech giant is aiming at the premium end of the smart speaker market, rather than competing with the low-price Amazon Echo Dot[9] or Google Home Mini[10]. The Wall Street Journal indicates that Samsung’s smart speakers could be introduced at different pricing tiers, suggesting the premium speaker could be paired with more affordable alternatives that could better compete against cheaper smart speakers such as the Amazon Echo (2nd Gen)[11] and Google Home[12] – similar to Samsung’s tiered strategy with smartphones. We would expect Samsung’s smart speakers to interface with Samsung’s SmartThings network[13] to control smart home products around your house, such as Philips Hue smart light bulbs.

The shape is also not known but many smart speakers are cylindrical and Samsung has used a similar shape before, such as with its R5 wireless speaker (pictured above). Discover Samsung’s record for speakers in our Samsung wireless speaker reviews[14].

Facebook’s Portal smart speaker with screen

Facebook has announced it will enter the smart speaker market in mid-2018 with two smart speakers with screens to rival the Amazon Echo Show[15]. With 15-inch laptop-size displays, they will be far larger than the Amazon Echo Show’s 7-inch screen (pictured below) and take the screen-speaker market to the next level.

They will be social-media focussed, with video chat and Facebook integration positioning the devices as ways for family and friends to stay in touch.

One of the models is reported to be called Portal, and will have both voice control and Face ID facial recognition to identify who is accessing Facebook through its front-facing camera. Facebook has already signed music-licensing contracts with two of the three global music giants – Universal Music and Sony, according to Patently Apple sources, which also revealed that this smart speaker is the first of an ecosystem of consumer video devices Facebook plans to launch over the next five years. While Facebook is the world leader in social media, recent studies suggest Snapchat is beginning to outcompete Facebook in the key 12-17-year-old teen demographic.

Facebook believes entering the music market with smart devices could help it reconnect with this teen audience.

Spotify’s hardware plans

Whether Spotify intends to release a smart speaker or not is uncertain, but what is clear is that it has plans to get into audio hardware, and this hardware aims to support its position as the world’s most popular music streaming service. Spotify job listings in April 2017 included a Senior Product Manager of Hardware for working on ‘a category defining product akin to Pebble Watch, Amazon Echo and Snap Spectacles’. Another listing indicated the audio hardware will include voice control, with a Product Manager of Voice ‘responsible for the strategy and execution of Spotify’s voice efforts beyond our core apps’ including in areas such as ‘desktop, TVs, speakers, cars, wearables, headphones’.

More recent job listings, including one for a Senior Project Manager: Hardware Production, suggest Spotify is now moving towards the hardware production stage. The move to produce hardware could be a response to many smart hardware rivals heavily promoting their own music streaming platforms. Apple has been the most aggressive, with Spotify not supported natively on either its Apple Watches or HomePod smart speaker.

Apple is not the only threat in the smart speaker space, with the two current biggest sellers of smart speakers – Amazon and Google – both having their own music streaming services to promote. Spotify may feel it needs to get into hardware to stay at the forefront in case Apple, Amazon and Google ultimately come to dominate the smart speaker market, or smart wearables market, in the future. Producing its own hardware would also give it an opportunity to directly influence the direction of audio hardware to best serve its Spotify music streaming platform.

We’ll have to wait and see what ‘category defining’ hardware product Spotify is working on.


  1. ^ Best Buy wireless speakers (
  2. ^ Echo Show (
  3. ^ Sonos One (
  4. ^ Sony LF-S50G (
  5. ^ LG speaker reviews (
  6. ^ Google Home. (
  7. ^ Apple HomePod (
  8. ^ Unlike the HomePod (
  9. ^ Amazon Echo Dot (
  10. ^ Google Home Mini (
  11. ^ Amazon Echo (2nd Gen) (
  12. ^ Google Home (
  13. ^ SmartThings network (
  14. ^ Samsung wireless speaker reviews (
  15. ^ Amazon Echo Show (

Apple HomePod: the best-sounding smart speaker yet?

One of the biggest wireless speaker releases of the year, the Apple HomePod is Apple’s first ever smart speaker and is likely to make a big impact on the market. It aims to raise the bar for the sound quality to expect from a compact wireless speaker and leave its rivals in the dust. Unlike competitor smart speakers from Amazon and Google with the Amazon Echo (2nd Gen)[1] and Google Home[2], Apple is touting the HomePod as a music player first and foremost and a voice assistant second.

Best Buy wireless and Bluetooth speakers[3] – see what the HomePod is up against. To achieve this ambition, internally it has seven tweeters for producing higher-frequency sounds, compared to just one on the Amazon Echo (2nd Gen) and Google Home. Like the Sonos One[4], it also optimises the sound it produces to match the shape of the room it’s in.

This means that in theory it attempts to distribute its sound evenly throughout – regardless of any odd-shaped corners in your room. The typical Apple build quality is on show here but, unusually, this is an exceptionally heavy speaker for its size at 2.5kg, making it rather like a shot put to lug around your home. What’s more, unfortunate early adopters have discovered that the silicone base of the heavy speaker can leave white marks on your home’s pristine wooden surfaces, which can be difficult to remove.

Apple has acknowledged the issue, giving recommendations on what to do[5] if this happens to you. Having a silicone base can help further improve sound – you can read our impressions on whether it’s worth it for the inconvenience, or whether its sound quality doesn’t make the grade regardless, in our HomePod first look review[6].

HomePod limitations

Earlier this month we also highlighted the significant limitations of the HomePod[7]. For example, Android smartphone users will have to look elsewhere, as you need an Apple device (newer iPhone, iPad or iPod Touch) to set it up.

In addition, the only music service natively supported by the speaker is Apple Music. There’s no direct support for popular alternatives such as Spotify. The only way you can access these is through AirPlay, so if you use other music streaming services such as Spotify, Tidal, Deezer or Amazon Music, see our recommendations[8] for alternatives to the HomePod.

In terms of smart functionality, Apple buries this quite far down in its list of what the HomePod can do. We get to the bottom of why this could be in our first look review. In the HomePod, Apple’s voice assistant Siri, which allows you to control your speaker with your voice and make additional commands such as asking it what the weather will be like, is competing directly with Amazon’s Alexa and Google’s Google Assistant.

Siri can perform a variety of tasks when you ask it to, such as read you text messages, add reminders for things to do later and create notes on your Apple device.

However, with Apple wanting to focus on the sound quality and the HomePod having been delayed beyond its original December launch date, we wanted to find out whether Siri can match the functionality of Alexa and Google Assistant.

To read all about this and our full first impressions of the HomePod’s sound quality, visit our Apple HomePod first look review[9].


  1. ^ Amazon Echo (2nd Gen) (
  2. ^ Google Home (
  3. ^ Best Buy wireless and Bluetooth speakers (
  4. ^ Sonos One (
  5. ^ recommendations on what to do (
  6. ^ HomePod first look review (
  7. ^ limitations of the HomePod (
  8. ^ our recommendations (
  9. ^ Apple HomePod first look review (

1 2 3 74